A big problem for rugby league’s overseas expansion plans – referees

Photo courtesy of Richard Long

In a week where Ottawa and New York have formally announced their brands and their entry to League One has been confirmed – there’s perhaps one question that’s been overlooked.

How can the RFL’s match officials department keep up with demand?

That was a question posed by former Super League referee Ian Smith, a recent guest on our Last Tackle podcast, and a passionate, knowledgable figure when it comes to the game.

If games are to be played in even just a couple of New York, Toronto, Toulouse, Perpignan and Ottawa over a given weekend, there is no way that match officials could double up.

That’s different to the current schedule – where a referee could feasibly be in the middle for a match on a Thursday, be the video referee at a different game on a Friday, and then run the line on a Sunday.

The match officials department is already struggling for numbers, and there is an ever increasing list of high-profile referee departures in recent years, including Phil Bentham, Joe Cobb, Richard Silverwood, Tim Roby and even Smith himself, who reluctantly hung up the whistle some 10 years ago.

With a concern that the level of abuse aimed towards referees – not helped by comments made by club chairmen and coaches in recent times – is already diminishing the numbers of match officials, to then have to find even more numbers and fast looks like a big challenge.

Games require a minimum of four officials, including the referee, a reserve and two touchjudges – while increasing that number to include in-goal officials and a possible video referee and even match commissioners and timekeepers puts yet more pressure on the numbers.

Overseas matches also put even more pressure on the pound – it’s not just about expenses for getting to a ground and officiating, you then have the fact you’re there for multiple days, meals and accommodation in that time, and the expense of overseas travel.

The RFL say that the additional costs of match officials are built in to the applications of overseas teams.

An RFL spokesperson said: “It’s a good point, and one which we always bear in mind, and will continue to do so – one of the many implications of inviting clubs from overseas into our domestic competitions.

“The development of match officials should be part of the planning for any new clubs, as although the new overseas clubs commit to covering the costs of the RFL supplying match officials, it also places considerable additional demands on our officials, the majority of whom are part-time.

“For example we have done training with all officials who are likely to travel overseas – full and part-time – delivered by Professor Dave Collins, former British Athletics Performance Director with extensive experience of high-performing athletes in how to handle international travel with short turnaround times.”

4 Comments

  1. Maybe the NRL could help out and supply junior referees and match officials in need of first grade time. Working in League One, the Championship, and even some Super League and Cup games.

    Also clubs could be given some leeway on salary cap if they sponsor the development of a number of match officials.

  2. How about the players playing to the rules, fans KNOWING the rules and the RFL supporting match officials and clamping down HARD on miscreants.
    Match officials were once well respected by players but the constant chirruping and arms flailing shows how little respect the players have for ANY authority, and coaches don’t even condemn them so must condone such action.
    Clamping down WILL be ugly and painful initially but pay dividends long term. This is not soccers which is now a joke beyond compare in sporting life. Sadly RL is going the same way unless strong action is taken

    • How about laymen video refs, looking at the footage with a neutral view point and given training and direction of the rules and bylaws, on televised matches they could be encouraged to speak the thought process leading to their decision and couldn’t get it wrong more often than the ex Wigan tinted pundits from sky sports, unless the laymen were also predominantly from that particular location!

  3. How about laymen video refs, looking at the footage with a neutral view point and given training and direction of the rules and bylaws, on televised matches they could be encouraged to speak the thought process leading to their decision and couldn’t get it wrong more often than the ex Wigan tinted pundits from sky sports, unless the laymen were also predominantly from that particular location!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*