Timing of ‘six-again’ rule introduction criticised, as buzzer confirmed

Catalans Dragons coach Steve McNamara has criticised the timing of the introduction of the new ‘six-again’ rule in Super League.

The regulation, which will see referees award fresh sets of tackles instead of penalties for certain offences around the ruck area, comes into the British game from the season’s resumption this Sunday.

The Rugby Football League has made the change – which is designed to improve the flow of games – to align with Australia’s NRL, where the rule was introduced earlier this year.

Former England coach McNamara told the PA news agency: “I’m a fan of the ‘six-again’ rule. I’m not opposed to it, it’s just the timing of when it’s come in.

“I do feel it is putting an excess load on the players that is not needed with the congestion and amount of games we have got to play, with midweek games, over a short period of time.

“For me, although it’s a good rule, I would have waited, based on those reasons and the fact some teams have played seven games with the old rules and we’ve only played four. It unbalances everything.

“But it is what it is. We’ll get on with it.”

The RFL has confirmed a buzzer will be used to communicate the awarding of another set under ‘six again’ in addition to the regular referee’s signal of waving a clenched fist from side to side above the head.

The new rule is one of two main changes introduced during the break in the season due to the Covid-19 pandemic, the other being the temporary removal of scrums on health grounds.

Huddersfield coach Simon Woolford is concerned about the impact the changes may have.

Woolford said at a press conference: “I’m sure there will be some blow-out scores early, I’m sure there will be some teams who adapt quicker to the new rules than others.

“There were a couple of blowouts early on in the NRL, and what we’ve seen also is a lot more injuries. A lot more ball in play, guys getting themselves into difficult positions in contact because they are fatigued – a lot of injuries are coming out of those sort of scenarios.”

Super League restarts on Sunday after a hiatus of more than four months with two games behind closed doors at Headingley. McNamara’s Catalans will face champions St Helens with Woolford’s Giants taking on Leeds.

In another coronavirus-enforced change, players will not be permitted to gather in huddles after the scoring of tries to limit the potential spread of infection.

Following approval of the changes by the RFL board, a newly-published guide states: “The team scoring a try should limit hugging or handshakes and the team conceding a try should not huddle closely behind their own line as the conversion is attempted.”

The guide also points out the removal of scrums was necessary to get the game being played again because the “microclimate” of six players in close proximity created “considerable risk of virus transmission”.


  1. Not a great fan of the timing of the revised rules but it would be a great thing for the game in general if we could implement the same rules throughout. It’s madness that the two major competitions, Super League and the NRL, are so different.
    We are one sport and therefore should have parity with the laws of the game.

  2. There would be no problem with the 6 again rule if the PLAYERS didn’t mess about at the play the ball. It really is that simple.
    As for eliminating scrums, downright stupidity. It’s one of the best attacking weapons in the game. The “player safety and corona virus “ protection is absolute guff.

  3. During lockdown we’ve all watched games from 10 years back or more, where players played the ball naturally. Recently the NRL games have started on Sky. The play the ball is mostly played to the rules.George Williams at Canberra plays the ball correctly now,much better than he did at Wigan. Next year 2021 we play the World Cup, Great Britain have fallen behind Australia, New Zealand and Tonga. We can’t afford to give away points and field positions just because of lazy play the balls. Ganson promised a crack down at the start of the season. If we don’t get a grip of this simple rule British Rugby League will suffer.

  4. Seems to me it rewards bad play. Already see teams happy to camp offside giving away six again on six again until error making defence easier without risking giving away penalties and points.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.