Brian McDermott comments: ashamed of rugby league?

Brian McDermott

Eyebrows were raised when Brian McDermott was appointed Featherstone coach following his controversial ‘small towns in the north’ comment when at Toronto.

But in trying to defend those comments, he has seemingly stuck the boot in further to Super League.

But for me, it begs the question – why are (some) people ashamed of rugby league?

McDermott on that Sky Sports interview

Brian McDermott made his comments after Toronto beat Featherstone in the 2019 Million Pound Game.

Speaking at Featherstone’s unveiling of three signings this week, he stood by the comments.

He said: “I was astonished that people thought having Toronto in Super League wasn’t a good idea. The point I was making was that the growth of Super League doesn’t lie any more with the small towns in the north of England.

But it was the wrong time to say it and it was insensitive of me to say that, given that people could have taken offence. I regret saying it on that platform at that stage but I stand by the comment.”

I don’t think it takes a rocket scientist to realise that in a perfect world, Super League would be made up of big city teams.

But there needs to be a sense of realism; and that’s surely one that current Super League owners are tuned in to.

Toronto’s demise was unfortunate given the context, but to stick the boot in to the places that have carried rugby league for more than 100 years was unnecessary.

COLUMN: 125 years of rugby league yet it still isn’t enough

Featherstone won’t grow Super League

McDermott’s task this year is to get Featherstone to the supposed promised land of Super League.

Given their efforts in the Championship over the past decade or so, on and off the field, they shouldn’t be begrudged that chance should they earn it.

On that, McDermott said: “I think if we get promoted, Featherstone would be a great addition to Super League. I think it’s a very good club that’s self-sustaining. But I don’t think Featherstone is going to grow Super League.

“I don’t think having Featherstone in Super League would make anybody from North America, South Africa, Asia, Russia or Australia take note. Not from any impactful degree.”

The question has to be why is it Super League’s responsibility for anyone in those areas to take notice.

Plus how realistic is it to do that given major locations like Liverpool, Manchester and Birmingham within touching distance of elite rugby league aren’t engaged.

On St Helens success

One of the growing criticisms of Super League is that there have been only four winners.

Leeds helped McDermott become the most successful coach in the competition’s history, but it is St Helens who are current holders.

Saints have won three titles in a row and are showing little sign of abating.

Whether Catalans winning the competition would make any noticeable difference remains to be seen; even a second French team and a Grand Final appearance hasn’t persuaded French broadcasters to invest.

He said: “What St Helens have done in winning three in a row is brilliant and they have my full respect for sure but Saints keeping winning Grand Finals is not going to grow Super League.”

Yet one of the biggest sports brands in the world, FC Barcelona, sent St Helens a congratulatory message following their latest success.

Toronto grabbing attention

We will never know what impact Toronto Wolfpack might have had on Super League.

The pandemic came at a typically inconvenient time for rugby league; but it was the Wolfpack’s shock Million Pound Game defeat to London that prevented them reaching the top flight sooner.

Brian McDermott added: “Toronto polarised opinions and it grabbed attention. Whether it’s negative or not doesn’t matter, it grabbed attention.”

Ultimately, Toronto existed because one man pumped in tens of millions until he didn’t anymore.

The recent North American Rugby League announcement is positive, if underwhelming.

It remains to be seen what legacy comes from the reported £20m investment.

There’s nothing stopping anyone investing similar amounts in whatever city they want.

But as seen, if not done right, it does little to grow the player pool or revenues from outside.

The impact of St Helens in its local community is significant; likewise, the fact Featherstone could have a professional sports team in a small conurbation should be a quirk and celebration of rugby league’s uniqueness.

Everyone wants rugby league to improve – sticking the boot in to its foundation and positives doesn’t help it to grow.

PLAY: Our free Fantasy Rugby League game is back for the 2022 season – pick your team now

About James Gordon 7044 Articles
Love Rugby League editor. Founded the website back in 2005. Worked with a range of clubs and sponsors during that time. Also commentates for BBC.

10 Comments

  1. I’m sorry Brian, but if you had still been the coach of the Rhino’s you would never be making these comments. These have only come about since you have had to ‘drop your sights’ and coach Championship Clubs. Rugby League has survived quite happily in our’small town Northern Clubs’ and slowly but surely is is quietly spreading through the Bronco’s….. the further North, the Welsh and more obviously, the French Provinces. Perhaps if you, Mr McDermot made more positive comments and welcomed more of the grass roots throughout both the UK and Europe we just might attract many more to our Rugby League family

  2. Agenda drive, pie in the sky nonsense. There is absolutely zero evidence that big cities are key to Rugby League survival. London have had 40+ years, have zero assets and are now part-time and about to play to three figure grounds in a stadium far too big for them. Paris and Toronto were poorly thought out and relied heavily on investors, who walked. Salford is a city and play in front of tiny crowds in a Lego stadium, Newcastle have potential but like Toronto, what happens when the money man stops putting his hands in his pockets, the only relatively big cities with any interest in Rugby League is Leeds, which is still a tiny percentage of the greater geographical area and Hull, which does its best for a city of its size. Pins in maps expansion and the sport of Rugby League taking the Lyle Langley approach of letting anyone in with a bit of money, without any strategic plan is daft, as is the premise that people in Bristol, Birmingham, Liverpool or Glasgow will suddenly turn out in their tens of thousands if someone magically plonks a rugby league team in their city.

  3. You small minded Dickheads.Rugby league has benefited from the vast amount of talented players in and around Fev.Congrats to a well organised club.

  4. These comments are neither based on the notion of an “ideal world” nor on the idea of accepting reality. They sum up the two problems for RL: one there’s not enough money in the sport and two how to change that forever. The comments are locked in the picture of an escape route based on big cities and essentially displays a lack of solutions and the will to put them into practice. It shows an administration and set of coaches too preoccupied with the percieved weaknesses of the sport and simplistic solutions. In the same way they’ll “downsize” SL in order to cope with less money, moving to a big city model reveals a sport bereft
    of ways forward after 125 years of nearly trying and mostly giving up.

  5. I fear for Featherstone, if they fail in their quest this season I wonder what next season will bring, all the eggs are in one basket….big names, bigger egos, bigger salaries …Sheffield tried and failed with this policy…

  6. I totally believe in maccas comments, this guy should be running the super league, he his one genuine rugby league guy who lives for rugby grass roots an all, but money and politics says different.

  7. Toronto Wolfpack hardly tried to grow RL either. They couldn’t even secure a North American TV deal which they were granted exclusive rights over, but then resorted to whining about not receiving money from the UK TV deal. The UK clubs get money for bringing UK audiences to tune into Sky Sport in the UK….A Canadian club shouldn’t get that money unless they’re bringing money in which they didn’t. The Wolfpack didn’t even update their YouTube channel or bother to do interviews in Canada to attract potential followers. How hard is that?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*